Skip to content

Reputation and Review Management for Eastern Shore Businesses

Pufferfish Media runs reputation management for local businesses on Maryland's Eastern Shore: automated review requests after each job, a reply to every review within 24 hours, monitoring across review sites, and a plan for the day a bad one lands. Plans start at $400 a month. Book 15 minutes with Adam and he'll look at your Google profile with you.

What's included

Automated review requests

When a job is marked complete in your CRM or field software, the customer gets a personal request by text and email while the work is still fresh. One follow-up goes out if there's no answer. We pace requests instead of blasting your whole customer list in one week, because a sudden pile of reviews looks manufactured to Google and to the people reading them. A steady run of recent reviews that mention the actual job and town is worth more.

Requests go to Google, or to Facebook for a customer who found you there. We don't ask for Yelp reviews: Yelp's own guidelines tell businesses not to, and its filter can hide reviews it thinks the business prompted. We monitor Yelp instead.

Review response management

Every review gets a reply within 24 hours. Positive reviews get a short, specific thank-you that names the work. Negative reviews get a calm reply that acknowledges the problem, doesn't argue the facts in public, and moves the conversation to a phone call. Replies are drafted with AI help and a person reads every one before it posts.

Online review monitoring

Starter covers Google and Facebook. Growth adds Yelp, the Better Business Bureau and the review sites for your trade, plus brand mentions on social media and the web. You get an alert when something new is posted, so a problem gets handled that day instead of weeks later.

Handling the bad ones

A crew has a bad week. A competitor posts. A former employee vents. A business with a similar name collects your complaints. We document what happened, report reviews that break the platform’s rules, help you resolve real complaints offline, and ask the customer to update the review once it’s fixed. We also clean up old listings that still show a disconnected number or an old address.

Your reviews on your website

We add a review widget to your site so visitors see what customers say. We don't add star-rating markup for your own business. Google stopped showing review stars for reviews a business collects about itself in 2019, so that markup buys nothing.

What we won't do

Some of what gets sold as reputation management breaks the rules, and the business owner carries the risk.

  • No paid or incentivized reviews. Google’s policy bans offering payment, discounts or free services for a review. So does the FTC rule on consumer reviews, in effect since October 21, 2024.
  • No review gating. Google bans "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers." Every customer gets the same request, happy or not.
  • No staff, family or agency reviews. Google treats reviews from current or former employees as a conflict of interest, and the FTC rule covers undisclosed insider reviews. We never write reviews for clients.
  • No deleting truthful reviews. Nobody can remove an honest negative review, and an agency that promises to is selling something that doesn’t exist. Reviews that break the rules can be reported. Honest ones get a good answer.

Why ratings move slowly

A star rating is an average, so every new review moves it a little less than the one before. Here's the math for a business with 40 reviews averaging 4.1:

Starting pointGoalNew five-star reviews needed
40 reviews, 4.1 average4.650
90 reviews, 4.6 average4.890

That's why we report trend, not totals, and why steady asking beats a one-time push. A business that already has a few hundred reviews moves even slower, which makes replies and recency matter more than the average itself.

How it works

  1. Benchmark.

    Your current rating, review count, how often new reviews arrive, and what they say, next to the two competitors ranking above you.

  2. Connect the request to the job.

    A completed job in your CRM or field software triggers the request.

  3. Answer everything.

    Every review gets a reply within 24 hours.

  4. Step in on the bad ones.

    Rule-breaking reviews get reported. Real complaints get worked out offline.

  5. Report monthly.

    Rating by platform over time, review count against your competitors, response times, and the themes in your reviews that point to something worth fixing in the business.

Pricing

Starter is $400 a month: the automated text and email requests, Google and Facebook monitoring, a monthly reputation report and a review widget for your website. Growth is $800 a month and adds AI-assisted reply drafting across all platforms, Yelp, BBB and trade-site monitoring, the negative-review workflow and a quarterly strategy session. See all plans on our pricing page.

Who it's for

This system was built on home-service businesses, starting with the founder's own roofing company. The same system works for medical offices, law firms, restaurants and auto shops. If customers pick you from the map pack, your reviews are doing sales work every day whether anyone manages them or not. For the ranking side of that, see our local SEO service.

Frequently asked questions

Can you remove negative reviews?
Only when a review breaks the platform's rules, such as spam, a review from a competitor, or a review for a business the person never used. We document and report those. A truthful negative review can't be deleted by anyone. A calm public reply and a steady flow of recent reviews make one bad experience read as the exception.
How do you get customers to leave reviews?
Pufferfish Media sends a personal text and email request as soon as a job is marked complete, while the work is fresh, with one follow-up if there's no response. Every customer gets the same request. No incentives, since paying for reviews breaks Google's rules and the FTC's.
Which review sites do you monitor?
Google and Facebook on every plan. The Growth plan adds Yelp, the Better Business Bureau, the review sites for your trade, and brand mentions across social media and the web, with an alert when anything new is posted.
How fast do you reply to reviews?
Within 24 hours. Speed matters most on negative reviews, because readers judge the reply as much as the complaint. Replies are drafted with AI help and checked by a person before they post.
What does reputation management cost?
Pufferfish Media's reputation management is $400 a month on the Starter plan and $800 a month on Growth. Starter covers review requests, Google and Facebook monitoring, a monthly report and a website review widget. Growth adds reply drafting on every platform, wider monitoring, the negative-review workflow and a quarterly strategy session.
How long does it take to improve my rating?
New reviews start arriving in the first month, but the average moves slowly once you have a lot of reviews. A business with 40 reviews at 4.1 needs 50 new five-star reviews to reach 4.6. Plan on months, not weeks.

See where your profile stands

Fifteen minutes with Adam. He looks at your Google profile and reviews live and names the two or three things holding you back. Book a call or call (443) 521-3491.

Web design and local SEO for the Eastern Shore

Calls are answered around the clock. After hours, an AI assistant takes a message and Adam calls you back.

Last updated